Behold: A study in Beige on White.
I know that's an uninspiring picture of shortbread. But I wanted to finish telling you about my entry in the Traditional Shortbread category of the Shortbread Baking contest at the Scottish Highland Games in Woodland CA, (see my last post) AND I need to perform the blogging equivalent of "Stop the presses!" because THIS recipe is FAR superior to the one I previously posted.
Let me tell you the odd way this came about.
There I was, having decided it was pointless to enter into the Traditional Shortbread contest because, really, what's to compete about? Shortbread is virtually defined by its basic simplicity. Shortbread is as shortbread does. Or something to that effect. But then as I said, my genetics kicked in and I was compelled to offer a traditional entry as well as non-traditional.
Meanwhile, after I posted my first article about the contest, a reader left a comment gently chiding me for referring to shortbread as a "cookie". In my defense, I pointed out that I was referring to Michael Ruhlman's book, "Ratio", in which he states that shortbread is in fact a basic cookie dough.
Fast forward to my own decision to enter the traditional recipe contest. Just for kicks, I do a quick Google search on the term "traditional shortbread" and found this little gem of an article, titled Scottish Shortbread, written by--of course!--Michael Ruhlman! Even more coincidentally, he posted this article on March 9 of this year, ,several weeks before I posted my article on shortbread. And even though I am a reader (and fan) of Michael's blog, this particular post got past me.
I made note of the fact that Michael's recipe was from a very traditional source: The Edinburgh Book Of Plain Cookery Recipes, published in 1920. I also noticed that the recipe calls for a portion of the flour to be substituted with rice flour, or alternatively, corn starch.
I didn't have any rice flour on hand, but the night before the contest I knew I had corn starch and all the other necessary ingredients in my pantry. So I used the Edinburgh recipe and whipped up a batch early on Saturday morning for the contest.
I decided to use my hands to mix the ingredients, and pat the dough into a round pan. As I worked the dough gently, I meditated on all the other Scottish women and men who had made this shortbread down through the decades. Maybe I was being overly romantic, but I felt connected to them that morning, in a kind of culinary lineage that blended with family ties that went all the way back through my Dad, to his Father whom I never met, back to my ancestors in Scotland.
I tasted a small bite of the shortbread after it finished baking. It tasted absolutely delicious, and I knew this was a superior recipe.
My shortbread was not a winning entry in the contest, but I noticed the judges lingered over it very thoughtfully. The flavor and color were right, as I learned later from the baker who took first place. But it was thin; I should have heeded Ruhlman's advice about making it thicker. Next time.
No matter. I claim a personal victory, for I have found a traditional shortbread recipe that is so, so, so good. It is now my new standard.
Turns out one shortbread recipe is NOT as good as another! Not by a long shot.
This shortbread is soooooo good. Out of deference and gratitude to Mr. Ruhlman, I'll recommend you find the recipe here on his site.
This is what I did:
INGREDIENTS
4 oz. flour
2 oz. corn starch
4 oz. butter
2 oz. (granulated) sugar
DIRECTIONS:
Sift flours together, then add all other ingredients and mix by hand, being careful not to overwork the dough. Pat the dough into a nine inch round cake pan* and place in pre-heated oven at 350 degrees F. Bake for 25 to 35 minutes, until shortbread is very light tan color. Allow to cool for 15 minutes before scoring with a knife to cut. When completely cooled, remove carefully from pan to slice and serve.
*Use a bread pan or smaller cake pan for thicker shortbread.